Windows 10: How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment...

Discus and support How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment... in Windows 10 Software and Apps to solve the problem; This is what I tried to post..." and what evidence is that? It sound like those idjits who screamed "Read the transcript, read the transcript" when... Discussion in 'Windows 10 Software and Apps' started by Murray Kenny, Jan 6, 2024.

  1. MURRAY KENNY
    Murray Kenny Win User

    How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment...


    This is what I tried to post..." and what evidence is that? It sound like those idjits who screamed "Read the transcript, read the transcript" when they themselves had not and had no idea what the transcript said. "I get the message "This comment doesn't meet the community guidelines. Please try another one.". So, I followed the link to the community guidelines, read them and still cannot see where the violation is. The guidelines say that if the comment is rejected, the writer will be presented with the message AND instructions on how to appeal. Guess what, there are no in

    :)
     
    Murray Kenny, Jan 6, 2024
    #1
  2. IPSLEUTH
    ipsleuth Win User

    I want to file multiple appeals on your community guidelines because perfectly reasonable comments keep getting rejected. However, I am unable to find any prompts or links to file the appeals.

    I want to file multiple appeals on your community guidelines because perfectly reasonable comments keep getting rejected. However, I am unable to find any prompts or links to file the appeals.
     
    ipsleuth, Jan 6, 2024
    #2
  3. WRMILES
    WRMILES Win User
    MSN.com appeals?

    There have been previous comments and questions on the arbitrariness of rejected comments on msn.com. Msn.com states the following under Guidelines:

    "When you request an appeal, our team of human moderators will review the comment. If they determine the comment was removed in error, it will be published immediately. All appeal decisions are final."

    I have not been able to find a button or link or other method to appeal. Does anybody know if there is one and does Microsoft ever respond?

    As usual, there does not seem to be a proper category for this question.
     
    WRMILES, Jan 6, 2024
    #3
  4. DON VARNAU
    Don Varnau Win User

    How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment...

    I want to file multiple appeals on your community guidelines because perfectly reasonable comments keep getting rejected. However, I am unable to find any prompts or links to file the appeals.

    Here's my canned response on moderation. Please see, in particular, points 4 & 5.

    1. You may find useful information at Microsoft News

    2. There were so many unacceptable comments that commenting was shut down for a few

    months not too long ago.

    3. Now that commenting is allowed again, moderation is very restrictive.

    4. Moderation is a dysfunctional mess. It's being done via AI, via a bot, not humans and is

    random and inexplicable.

    5. If a comment you tried to post was banned, you can appeal that from the Feedback link

    at the bottom of nearly every MSN page. This may or may not be acted on and you may

    or may not receive a reply. There used to be a more direct method, but that's been removed.

    6. I've searched but have not found a way to contact MSN staff regarding this moderation

    except the Feedback link that's at the bottom of nearly every MSN webpage. If you receive

    a reply to the feedback, it will be a generic reply that doesn't address your specific issue.

    Don
     
    Don Varnau, Jan 6, 2024
    #4
Thema:

How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment...

Loading...

  1. How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment... - Similar Threads - does really actually

  2. Comment Removed, Appealed, Won Appeal, comment still hidden.

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    Comment Removed, Appealed, Won Appeal, comment still hidden.: If a post is removed from msn.com, is then appealed, the appeal is won and yet the comment is still “hidden” what could be the cause of this? By MSN’s own admission the comment doesn’t violate their terms, yet they still hide it because they disagree with what I said?...

  3. Comment Removed, Appealed, Won Appeal, comment still hidden.

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Comment Removed, Appealed, Won Appeal, comment still hidden.: If a post is removed from msn.com, is then appealed, the appeal is won and yet the comment is still “hidden” what could be the cause of this? By MSN’s own admission the comment doesn’t violate their terms, yet they still hide it because they disagree with what I said?...

  4. Why was this comment rejected?

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Why was this comment rejected?: I'd like one of the uneducated and obviously Russian trolls who works the Microsoft Start page to explain to me why the following comment violates community standards."There is no First Amendment right to hold someone against their will. There is also no First Amendment right...

  5. Why was this comment rejected?

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    Why was this comment rejected?: I'd like one of the uneducated and obviously Russian trolls who works the Microsoft Start page to explain to me why the following comment violates community standards."There is no First Amendment right to hold someone against their will. There is also no First Amendment right...

  6. HOW DO YOU APPEAL AN UNJUSTIFIABLE BAN

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    HOW DO YOU APPEAL AN UNJUSTIFIABLE BAN: I was banned from making comments, however, an unjustifiable ban. My comments have never, ever violated the community guidelines. And never will. It is unfortunate how MSN has allowed people who do not agree with my opinion, and that is their right, to take advantage of...

  7. HOW DO YOU APPEAL AN UNJUSTIFIABLE BAN

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    HOW DO YOU APPEAL AN UNJUSTIFIABLE BAN: I was banned from making comments, however, an unjustifiable ban. My comments have never, ever violated the community guidelines. And never will. It is unfortunate how MSN has allowed people who do not agree with my opinion, and that is their right, to take advantage of...

  8. How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment...

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    How does one really, actually, where do you file an appeal for a rejection of a comment...: This is what I tried to post..." and what evidence is that? It sound like those idjits who screamed "Read the transcript, read the transcript" when they themselves had not and had no idea what the transcript said. "I get the message "This comment doesn't meet the community...

  9. Where do I appeal the numerous appropriate comments I make that keep getting flagged ?

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    Where do I appeal the numerous appropriate comments I make that keep getting flagged ?: I have had multiple comments on Microsoft news articles that were all appropriate blocked at least 3 times a week . Can someone please tell me where I’m supposed go for an appeal because I have received no notification in my email from Microsoft telling me the reason or...

  10. Where do I appeal the numerous appropriate comments I make that keep getting flagged ?

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Where do I appeal the numerous appropriate comments I make that keep getting flagged ?: I have had multiple comments on Microsoft news articles that were all appropriate blocked at least 3 times a week . Can someone please tell me where I’m supposed go for an appeal because I have received no notification in my email from Microsoft telling me the reason or...