Windows 10: How smart is SMART now?

Discus and support How smart is SMART now? in Windows 10 News to solve the problem; Your disks and SSDs have a self-monitoring function called SMART. But how good is it? The fine folks at Backblaze are back with data on how well SMART... Discussion in 'Windows 10 News' started by Brink, Nov 11, 2014.

  1. Brink
    Brink New Member

    How smart is SMART now?


    Read more...

    :)
     
    Brink, Nov 11, 2014
    #1

  2. is N95 is as smart as the name (smart phone)?

    Hi, i bought N95 (previously i am using N73 ME).

    i found many drawbacks in N95, here are few...

    1. With N95 we have a feature of AV out. But , its suited for image and video viewing. upto this its ok. but when coming to browsing, the web page is not resized to the TV resolution to fit to TV screen size.

    i feel it should have a feature to identify the device resolution and switch to that resoluion on demand by the user, when he connected to TV while on browsing. with

    this we can almot replace a computer.

    2.when connected to TV via AV, the mobile screen is ON, it should have a feature to turn Off mobile display.

    3. in N73 we can resend any messages (bluetooth messages and images, 3gp files) from inbox via bluetooth or Ir. But N95 lags this feature.

    4. Camera tool bar is not colorful as N73.

    5. Ram size is low

    i want teke these issues to Nokia Developers...some one pls help...
     
    sureshsreddy, Nov 11, 2014
    #2
  3. patc---01 Win User
    is N95 is as smart as the name (smart phone)?

    The best way to contact Nokia is via the "Contact Us" link in the top right of this page.

    Not sure you'll get much joy from them with these issues, though: most sound like "features" as opposed to "bugs".
     
    patc---01, Nov 11, 2014
    #3
  4. badrobot Win User

    How smart is SMART now?

    Thanks! Good info.

    The SMARTEST thing to do is to make back-ups. We should always assume that hard drives will fail without a warning. *Smile
     
    badrobot, Nov 11, 2014
    #4
  5. X2!
     
    Lady Fitzgerald, Nov 11, 2014
    #5
  6. LMiller7 Win User
    SMART provides a valuable warning of potential drive failure. But no warning can be relied on to protect you from data loss.

    The time between receiving the warning and drive failure may be too short to recover your data.
    SMART can only warn of certain types of drive failure. There are failures, such as in the drive electronics, where it will provide no warning at all. Many drive failures occur with no warning at all and for no apparent reason.

    And warnings are of no use unless they are heeded. I have seen so many cases on forums that go something like this:

    The hard drive starts to make strange noises, possibly with SMART warnings at bootup. Other errors develop. No action is taken. Finally:

    "HELP!! My computer won't start. It contains very valuable files and I have no backups"

    By then it is often too late.

    The best protection against data loss is regular backups made when there are no warnings or symptoms. You do this because the drive may fail with no warning. Or one of many other things may happen. When a SMART warning occurs you take extra care. Be very sure your backs are in good order and maybe make another one, just in case. Be prepared to replace the drive in the near future.
     
    LMiller7, Nov 11, 2014
    #6
  7. I used to think that SMART would give advanced warnings of drive failures, but this year, I've had two Seagate drives fail on me suddenly without any indications at all! In both cases, the drives were working fine one day and dead the next. I have to agree with one of the conclusions in the article in that SMART is useless for warning about impending drive failures.
     
    Mark Phelps, Nov 12, 2014
    #7
  8. LMiller7 Win User

    How smart is SMART now?

    SMART does provide valuable warnings of drive failure. It is just that you can't rely on them. Big difference.
    Many warnings outside of computers are like this. The "Check engine" light in a car offers valuable warning that something is wrong and needs to be looked into. But the lack of a warning doesn't mean all is well.

    You cannot rely on SMART to detect drive failure. That would require the ability to predict the future. For all the advances made in science that is beyond it's abilities.
     
    LMiller7, Nov 12, 2014
    #8
  9. BillyBob Win User
    I've NEVER had a warning by SMART, and have had a few HDDs fail. I agree with Mark Phelps. Even when the drives have been sqealing and groaning, nothing showed up in SMART.
     
    BillyBob, Nov 13, 2014
    #9
  10. CountMike New Member
    SMART does provide valuable information but it's retroactive, only in cases when something already happened. Should be checked at some intervals, after something happens to disk it maybe late. Problem is interpreting results, most of SW shows cryptic data to untrained eyes. There are many programs for checking disks and SMART alike : Download Passmark DiskCheckup - MajorGeeks but best bet is to use some application provided by drive's manufacturer.
    Health and Performance indicators in SMART monitoring are on the other hand speculative from the side of manufacturer, had many cases when Health was indicated as very poor but disk still worked flawlessly, that's because of some problems that happened in the past but was rectified, poor data and power cable connections at some time in the past or software induced bad sectors repaired since live mark in SMART and that mark can't be reversed even if repairs were successful.
    I'm not sure about newer Windows but XP for instance would not install if SMART was enabled and was showing bad disk. Turning off SMART monitoring in BIOS would let you install XP but with bad drive it was iffy to say at least.
     
    CountMike, Nov 13, 2014
    #10
  11. wotevfir Win User
    I have had trouble with the new 'green' drives failing, even brand new. Went on amazon and found a discussion as to which country they are assembled. So I ordered and returned, until I received the correct country and they are correct: testing software proved it. Some drives were half the speed of others: same name, from different country!
     
    wotevfir, Jan 19, 2015
    #11
  12. CountMike New Member
    Well, there was that flood in Thailand few years ago.
     
    CountMike, Jan 19, 2015
    #12
  13. How smart is SMART now?

    Well, there was that flood in Thailand few years ago. True that but those HDDs should be long gone by now. I've had only two WD Greens fail on me so far: the first was one of the early Greens that had the excessive head parking issue (that has long since been corrected) that never should have been installed as a sole drive by a computer shop that should have known better (one of the two the main reasons I broke down and learned how to build and maintain my own machines) and one that started showing SMART errors (over 300 reallocated sectors) before the factory warranty ran out and WD promptly replaced. Right now, I have ten Greens, four of which I bought recently and I am now "torture" testing (running multiple wipes for a about a week each drive). I use my Greens only for backups.

    For my internal drives, I prefer WD Blacks. They are noticeably snappier and come with the longer warranty (five years) so are more likely to be more durable than the Greens.

    I prefer to buy my Greens from NewEgg since I can buy an additional three years of "warranty" (technically, it's a service plan) for a reasonable price, giving me a full five years of warranty. Blacks I can get from Amazon or NewEgg, depending on who sells them for less but prefer Amazon because if a drive shows up DOA (considering how poorly carriers handle them, it's surprising DOAs aren't any more frequent than they already are), I don't have to pay for return shipping.
     
    Lady Fitzgerald, Jan 19, 2015
    #13
  14. jimbo45 Win User
    Hi there

    I'd switch to SSD's if I were you - they are getting to almost mainstream HDD price. It won't be too long before spinners are obsolete in domestic environments. Less power, less heat, less mnanufacturing materials etc. SSD's lifecycle is just as good as or even better than spinners now anyway.

    I did see some stupid imbecilic person from "The Green Party" over here saying another reason you should avoid using standard HDD's is that they can cause "Cranial Magnetic Stimulation" in Humans. !!!!!

    Well there's always some strange people around -- seriously though SSD's are so superior in performance it's worth it unless you are talking high storage volumes. Even the 1TB sizes are now beginning to reach mainstream level of affordability.

    For decent warning of imminent HDD failures - forget SMART - simply use the Storage spaces feature - where you can aggregate a pool (i.e 2 or more) of volumes into a single storage space. The volumes can be of different sizes and you can specify a % of the space to be set aside for recovery and data integrity -- you shouldn't need more than 25% in an extreme case. Now if a volume starts to fail you can organise a recovery and REMOVE the failing volume from the pool. You can dynamically also ADD more volumes at any time. - Works MUCH MUCH better than RAID where the volumes need to be THE SAME SIZE and you are using 50% for mirroring.

    Cheers
    jimbo
     
    jimbo45, Jan 19, 2015
    #14
  15. wotevfir Win User
    Watch out for earlier SSD, had bad experience with OC a few years ago; worth reading hardware testing site reports, before purchase. Also nowhere near enough storage space, but love PC start, from off in 30 seconds, against 90, on a 3GB/s drive. That minute is irritating, especially on a laptop!

    Amazon were still selling assembled in C HD's until recently. I managed to purchase assembled somewhere else ones, after several tries; they last for years...
     
    wotevfir, Jan 19, 2015
    #15
Thema:

How smart is SMART now?

Loading...
  1. How smart is SMART now? - Similar Threads - smart SMART

  2. I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device.

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device.: I have an ECHO DOT. I have AMAZON ALEXA on my windows 10 PC. I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device. It says on the device it works with Alexa. Any ideas ?...
  3. I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device.

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device.: I have an ECHO DOT. I have AMAZON ALEXA on my windows 10 PC. I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device. It says on the device it works with Alexa. Any ideas ?...
  4. I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device.

    in Windows 10 Installation and Upgrade
    I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device.: I have an ECHO DOT. I have AMAZON ALEXA on my windows 10 PC. I just purchased a SMART PLUG from AMAZON but am unable to get it to recognize the device. It says on the device it works with Alexa. Any ideas ?...
  5. Enable smart app control

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    Enable smart app control: Hello, I have a Windows 11 PC with smart app control off. I would like to enable but for this I need to reset my PC. My question is if I reset my PC will it keep Windows 11 or will it reset to Windows 10 which was installed before I upgraded to win 11, so will it reset to win...
  6. Enable smart app control

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Enable smart app control: Hello, I have a Windows 11 PC with smart app control off. I would like to enable but for this I need to reset my PC. My question is if I reset my PC will it keep Windows 11 or will it reset to Windows 10 which was installed before I upgraded to win 11, so will it reset to win...
  7. Windows Lag Due to Smart audio 3

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    Windows Lag Due to Smart audio 3: Recently I bought a second-hand mobile workstation. It is an HP Zbook studio g5 Mobile workstation. Everything is fine with this device but I'm facing a lag issue with it. 1 out of 3 times when the laptop is turned on it starts to lag the windows or mouse. Not every time but...
  8. Windows Lag Due to Smart audio 3

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Windows Lag Due to Smart audio 3: Recently I bought a second-hand mobile workstation. It is an HP Zbook studio g5 Mobile workstation. Everything is fine with this device but I'm facing a lag issue with it. 1 out of 3 times when the laptop is turned on it starts to lag the windows or mouse. Not every time but...
  9. Due to intel smart sound technology, the microphone stopped working

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    Due to intel smart sound technology, the microphone stopped working: I install the drivers for sound, and along with the drivers, intel smart sound was downloaded, after which there was a hiss from my microphone, while the sound was...
  10. Due to intel smart sound technology, the microphone stopped working

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Due to intel smart sound technology, the microphone stopped working: I install the drivers for sound, and along with the drivers, intel smart sound was downloaded, after which there was a hiss from my microphone, while the sound was...