Windows 10: Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc.

Discus and support Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc. in Windows 10 Gaming to solve the problem; I'm using Windows 11 and the firewall rules have been changing by themselve often. I can leave everything as it is, check back an hour later and... Discussion in 'Windows 10 Gaming' started by Robert Ambros, Dec 11, 2024.

  1. Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc.


    I'm using Windows 11 and the firewall rules have been changing by themselve often. I can leave everything as it is, check back an hour later and privately checked without public rules go to public. If i install some software such as steam especially the steam client and its helepr automatically go to public. I dont have steam installed now, and have been monitoring the issue. Now I a new item which is greyed out is set to private and public rules checked. Before this , this item did not exist, as there were no public rules checked at all in the list. Any help or suggestions would be ni

    :)
     
    Robert Ambros, Dec 11, 2024
    #1
  2. david_ooo Win User

    How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD

    Hello,

    I would like to modify firewall rule in CMD to have unblocked RDP.

    I have found this command somewhere:

    but it adds a new rule "Open Remote Desktop". I want to modify an existing, which is "Remotedesktop". How to do this from Command Line? I want also know how to reverse the rule to block RDP - in CMD as well. Thank you in advance.
     
    david_ooo, Dec 11, 2024
    #2
  3. TwuTu Win User
    Windows Firewall: Doesn't show blocking rules

    Hello!

    Today I've blocked all connections of a program by creating a outbound rule in Windows Firewall. However, I now wish to remove it. The problem: I can't find that newly created rule anywhere in the list. The rule does take an effect, since deactivating the
    Firewall lets the program run properly. I can only see rules in the list that "allow" stuff, but not those who block things.

    What I have tried so far:

    - All filters set to "Show all" within the Firewall

    - Created the same rule again, doesn't show up

    - Created a rule that allows the program, shows up

    Any solutions?
     
    TwuTu, Dec 11, 2024
    #3
  4. mike1127 Win User

    Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc.

    firewall rule to block addresses NOT on an IP list?


    I am just starting to learn the Windows Firewall (working on both Windows 7 and 10) and I'm not impressed with the inflexibility of its rules. I would like to know if


    1. Is there is a way to do what I want with Windows Firewall?
    2. Is there is a third-party firewall that would do it?


    What I want to do is create a rule that blocks outgoing connections, for program X, that are to a destination **NOT** in an IP list.


    Windows Firewall is not very flexible in how you specify IP list rules. When you give an IP list, your rule will match that list... you can't say "trigger the rule for non-matching IP addresses." Therefore to allow outgoing connections to a list, you have to


    1. Change the entire firewall policy to block outgoing connections by default so that you can create an "allow rule" matching your list. This will mess up the rest of your programs.


    2. Somehow combine a block rule and allow rule. Create a block rule for most traffic, with the "allow" rule overriding it when appropriate. However, this doesn't appear to be possible in general. It **may** be possible for connections that use IPSec, I'm not sure. And I'm not sure if I can use IPSec in my application.

    And is there a third-party firewall that can do it? Most 3rd-party firewalls are LESS sophisticated than Windows Firewall, because the use case they are addressing is providing an interface that doesn't require much comprehension. I need one that's actually MORE sophisticated than Windows Firewall.
     
    mike1127, Dec 11, 2024
    #4
Thema:

Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc.

Loading...
  1. Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc. - Similar Threads - Win11 Firewall rules

  2. Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc.

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Win11 Firewall rules changing by themselves, from nonchecked, to non-existant rule, etc.: I'm using Windows 11 and the firewall rules have been changing by themselve often. I can leave everything as it is, check back an hour later and privately checked without public rules go to public. If i install some software such as steam especially the steam client and its...
  3. Windows Firewall Rule

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Windows Firewall Rule: I am not very familiar with Windows Firewall and have some questions:Inbound and Outbound Rules1-1. In what situations should inbound and outbound rules be created?1-2. Since communication typically involves a pair of request and response actions, do I need to create outbound...
  4. How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD

    in Windows 10 Gaming
    How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD: Hello,I would like to modify firewall rule in CMD to have unblocked RDP.I have found this command somewhere:netsh advfirewall firewall add rule name="Open Remote Desktop" protocol=TCP dir=in localport=3389 action=allow profile=domainbut it adds a new rule "Open Remote...
  5. How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD: Hello,I would like to modify firewall rule in CMD to have unblocked RDP.I have found this command somewhere:netsh advfirewall firewall add rule name="Open Remote Desktop" protocol=TCP dir=in localport=3389 action=allow profile=domainbut it adds a new rule "Open Remote...
  6. How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD

    in AntiVirus, Firewalls and System Security
    How to modify existing firewall rule from CMD: Hello,I would like to modify firewall rule in CMD to have unblocked RDP.I have found this command somewhere:netsh advfirewall firewall add rule name="Open Remote Desktop" protocol=TCP dir=in localport=3389 action=allow profile=domainbut it adds a new rule "Open Remote...
  7. Firewall rules

    in Windows 10 Network and Sharing
    Firewall rules: [ATTACH] Does this symbol mean I have blocked outbound traffic for an application? If so why did the app just check for an update and confirm its current version? https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/firewall-rules/870791a0-328a-4d5c-ad0a-be99f93dfdb0
  8. Firewall Rules

    in Windows 10 Network and Sharing
    Firewall Rules: Can you setup exceptions for firewall rules? For example, if I have a port blocked inbound for ALL via GPO, can I create an exception to that rule to allow just certain IP addresses to get through the port being blocked? Win 10 ENT in a domain environment....
  9. Firewall rules

    in AntiVirus, Firewalls and System Security
    Firewall rules: I accidentally deleted outbound windows firewall rules. Will these reappear? Can this be dangerous? Please help. Thanks https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_10-security/firewall-rules/1f7cbdda-d9e2-435a-96cb-6caef7699b88"
  10. Firewall rules resetting

    in AntiVirus, Firewalls and System Security
    Firewall rules resetting: For some reason I'm not able to keep my firewall settings saved. Specifically, apps that I allow through the firewall whether through prompt or control panel reset back to "not allowed.' I think this is happening after each update. It's extremely frustrating as I primarily...