Windows 10: Exploding batteries: A serious charge

Brink · Oct 23, 2016

With Samsung looking at a $4 billion-plus hit due to the Galaxy Note 7's explosive lithium-ion battery problems, how are the alternative technologies shaping up?

Phone companies often talk about bang-per-buck, but rarely mean it literally. Explosive devices are unpopular outside battle zones, so when the Galaxy Note 7, Samsung's now-discontinued flagship smartphone, started to combust in appreciable numbers, something was obviously wrong. The culprit proved to be the lithium ion (Li-ion) battery -- unsurprisingly, as that component stores the energy needed to run all the advanced electronics, high-speed radio links and large, bright screen that characterise today's top-tier handsets.

It's at this point that physics, marketing and expectation come into conflict. Users expect more brightness, more processing power and more features with every phone generation, but are not prepared to trade off phone slimness or life between charges. The Galaxy Note 7 battery stores 3,500 milliamp-hours (mAh), which at 3.7 volts checks in at around 13 watt-hours (Wh) -- all in a very slim, light package. That might not sound much, but Li-ion batteries are very good at accepting and delivering power quickly, which is what makes them the default technology for electric cars such as those made by Tesla.

It's not such a good idea in the trouser department. If all the power in a fully-charged Note 7 battery was used up in ten seconds, it would clock in at 4 kilowatts, which is the equivalent of several hundred bunsen burners in your pocket. As Li-ion batteries contain pressurised, combustible materials, the result of an internal short circuit -- when the battery will indeed do its best to produce as much energy as quickly as possible -- are spectacular. This is probably what happened in the Galaxy Note 7, due to distortions produced in the battery by the case, although we await the final report.

This, of course, is unacceptable, even if the fault occurs one time in a million -- the sort of level that in any other component would be hard to detect even by statistical' analysis. With tens of millions of some units in the field, and social media able to fan the flames, it doesn't take much to kill a product.

Image: ZDNet / Data: BatteryUniversity.com

Li-ion batteries were considered too dangerous for general consumer use when first invented in the 1970s. However, lithium is a superb material for batteries -- it's the lightest metal, with excellent electronic properties -- and after considerable work on safe construction and use, Sony produced the first consumer-grade batteries in 1991. All early Li-ion batteries used a liquid electrolyte -- the medium that allows ions to move between electrodes and thus electricity to flow. In 1994, the first economic polymer electrolyte matrix was announced, which is much safer, better able to be formed in different shapes, and increases energy density without increasing volume. Even so, it took until 2009 before the first lithium-polymer (Li-poly) batteries appeared in consumer products.

Given that lithium-based batteries have attracted by far the most investment and commercial interest in the mobile power market, it's clear that significant improvements in battery technology take a long time to reach production. With Li-ion technology still improving at around five percent a year, alternative approaches face a fearsome challenge. But as Samsung has learned to its cost, today's batteries are far from perfect.

Here are the frontrunners to answer this burning question...
Click to expand...

Read more: Exploding batteries: A serious charge | ZDNet

bobad · Oct 25, 2016

Li-Ion/Li-Po are damaged but not dead. Li-Ion cells can be made safe. There are millions out there used and abused with no failures. Only when there are design or quality defects do they catch fire. Miniaturization is the main culprit. It's easy to make a small Li-Ion battery, it's easy to make a safe Li-Ion battery, it's much harder to make a small, safe Li-Ion pack.

If I were Samsung, I would be going after my battery pack supplier, though they may manufacture their own. Oops.

:)

crea2k---01 · Oct 25, 2016

Better Battery for the N95?

As far as I know the phone stops charging once it is fully charged anyways as if you look at the charging bar that moves it no longer moves it has finished charging, I would say the phone has a electronic switch that turns off the power going to the battery
once it is full otherwise the battery would explode, if you force over charge a lithium battery it can explode so I should think nokia has a safe guard built into the phones to turn off the power reaching the battery once charged or there would be lots of
people having exploding phones in the middle of the night.

Ashe13 · Oct 25, 2016

First charging.

I bought a new Nokia 1280 the basic model. Super basic... How long do I have to charge it? [Will my battery explode if I charge overnight from like 11pm to 6am] [...] = after first charge, another question.

Winuser · Apr 4, 2018

I think it's like a lot of things today. They put profit first and quality last.

Windows 10: Exploding batteries: A serious charge

Exploding batteries: A serious charge

Exploding batteries: A serious charge

Exploding batteries: A serious charge

Exploding batteries: A serious charge - Similar Threads - Exploding batteries serious

I think my battery will explode

I think my battery will explode

I think my battery will explode

battery charging

Battery not charging

Battery not charging

Battery not charging

Battery is not charging

Battery not charging