Windows 10: RollBack MX and Macrium Reflect

Discus and support RollBack MX and Macrium Reflect in Windows 10 Backup and Restore to solve the problem; I understand that the two don't play so well together. If I have both installed, and I restore using MR, I understand that I run a risk of an... Discussion in 'Windows 10 Backup and Restore' started by shmu26, Jan 27, 2016.

  1. shmu26 Win User

    RollBack MX and Macrium Reflect

    I understand that the two don't play so well together.
    If I have both installed, and I restore using MR, I understand that I run a risk of an unbootable system.
    Question: can I fix that by simply uninstalling RB at its pre-windows screen, where you press "home"?
    And then running the MR repair boot tool, if necessary?
    Or is that no guarantee to success?
    I don't care if I have to uninstall RB and lose my snapshots. I am using the free version anyways, and I don't care about the snapshots. I just want an intact windows system to emerge from the mess, in the rare case that I have to restore using MR.

    shmu26, Jan 27, 2016
  2. SpiritX MS MVP, Jan 27, 2016
  3. Ed-jo Win User
    Issues with Macrium Reflect and SyncToy programs Windows 10.

    trying to create a task for synctoy, or any other program fails, also scheduler not working for macrium reflect either, any help appreciated.

    Old title: cant create a task get multiple errors.
    Ed-jo, Jan 27, 2016
  4. b1rd Win User

    RollBack MX and Macrium Reflect

    Hey shmu26-

    I waited to see what other suggestions were made, as I'm not sure I understand the issue, exactly. There's not been any thus far, so this is what I was wondering:

    Can't you just run each one, one at a time? I mean disable them from auto-starting, then activate / launch them as needed?

    I know if you have this set up for scheduled back-ups / snapshots, then that won't work, but just a thought.

    Also, IMHO, if don't feel comfortable with RollBack, but want a second layer of back ups, then it might be worth looking into uninstalling it, and installing AOMEI, which is another free imaging program.
  5. shmu26 Win User
    thanks for suggestions.
    The main problem is that an image made by macrium reflect or other imaging software will contain a hidden boot partition that belongs to Rollback RX. You can't get rid of that boot partition just by disabling the program at startup.
    So when you do a restore with your favorite imaging software, the boot process gets all confused.

    I read a post from someone who was very happy with his macrium-rollback combination, although he was on MBR legacy boot.
    So I decided to give it a try with my EUFI boot, using his recommendation to immediately run the macrium boot repair tool, right after restore.

    Basically, this worked for me, although I had to run it a couple times, with a boot or two in-between, because Rollback did not get killed. It didn't die until I booted into windows (although windows didn't work quite right), and then tried to restore my system from a Rollback snapshot.
    I think the right procedure is to restore the macrium image, immediately run the macrium boot repair tool, and then, if Rollback is still alive, to hit the "home" key when the Rollback pre-windows screen splashes. Then, choose "uninstall". After successfully booting to your desktop, you reinstall Rollback.

    The company that makes Rollback RX also makes an imaging software, called Drive Cloner Rx, and they say it plays nicely with Rollback. But they don't have a free edition yet, just a 30-day trial.

    As for comparing AOMEI or any other imaging program to Rollback, it's just no comparison. Rollback is so quick and so convenient, you wouldn't believe it. But it runs your whole system inside some kind of a virtualized enviroment or something (I am not techie enough to define it properly), so you can't properly perform on-the-metal functions such as resizing your partitions, modifying the MBR, running TRIM, etc. So if you want to do stuff like that, you have to uninstall and reboot, because otherwise, the Rollback environment will be there between you and the metal, and things can really mess up.

    At the end of the day, though, the Macrium Reflect boot repair tool does the job, like I said.
    shmu26, Jan 28, 2016
  6. b1rd Win User
    Ok, I think I get the idea now. I'm not familiar enough with Rollback, so I really don't know.

    RollBack sounds a lot like a program that I once used years ago called "GoBack." This would load just before Windows and offered a brief splash screen, which allowed the option to go back in time, even if Windows failed to boot. It did get a big buggy and I subsequently had to boot into Safemode to uninstall it. But it was great when I needed it.

    I've always been a bit leery of using programs that load just before Windows in case they get buggy, but Win-10 seems to have more recovery options than the OS I had back then, so it might not become much of an issue if it were to happen.

    You also have a built in Windows Imaging utility which you can configure to run daily. It seems to just write the new image over the old one, thus keeping only one image available to save space. If you change the name of the image, it will write another only along side, so you'll have two.

    It's no RollBack, but it does offer an added layer of recovery options.
  7. shmu26 Win User
    Right. Rollback also has a problem with some of the windows updates. And if you have a HDD, defragmenting the regular way can mess things up. So basically, it is a magic tool if you are willing to take the risk it involves. And you definitely should have a second backup plan.
    But it is probably healthier in the long run to resist the urge to tinker recklessly with the PC, than it is to have a quickie way to recover from user-generated mistakes.
    shmu26, Apr 5, 2018

RollBack MX and Macrium Reflect

  1. RollBack MX and Macrium Reflect - Similar Threads - RollBack Macrium Reflect

  2. Macrium Reflect Difficulties

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect Difficulties: Hi all I've got an issue with imaging using Macrium Reflect Free. I'm running a dual boot system using Bootcamp with Windows 7 & 10 on two primary partitions on my iMac 24. Both work perfectly but if I run Macrium Reflect on either one of the two OS's, the Windows 10...
  3. Macrium Reflect Download

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect Download: I went to the Macrium website to download Macrium Reflect and found that there is a "trial" version and a "full" version. I've seen it posted on this forum that Macrium Reflect is free, but this doesn't seem to be accurate. Am I missing something? 66707
  4. Macrium reflect free

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium reflect free: Now it will not reinstall saying it cannot find the target I am going to run sfc then dism
  5. Macrium Reflect

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect: Where are instructions for Macrium Reflect ? Don Cole 101495
  6. Macrium Reflect update

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect update: Hello, While making a weekly backup (differential or full) with Macrium version 6, I was notifyedthere is an update for this version, downloaded and installed the update.Then opened the product's site and saw there is a new version - 7, on one page it says free editionhere...
  7. Macrium Reflect Disaster

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect Disaster: W10 Pro, 16GB RAM, 480Gb SSD Macrium Reflect Free v. 6.3.1835.0, attempting to image drive C:\. After several hours, image failed to complete. System would not reboot in any way, not from CD/DVD drive, Flash drive etc., Ubuntu.. Data on C and other HD OK. Attempt to...
  8. Macrium Reflect...

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect...: Hi all, Having just upgraded to the latest Window 10 CU I am now looking for so good back up software... For a number of years I have been using Memeo instant back up, and the version I have now it old so an update is required even though it still does it's job........
  9. Macrium Reflect Free

    in Windows 10 Software and Apps
    Macrium Reflect Free: Good Day All just curious if this looks right [img] the fourth section of my C: drive is all red meaning full (almost) is this normal Thanks in ADV for any info 97310
  10. Macrium Reflect errors.

    in Windows 10 Support
    Macrium Reflect errors.: Okay so I booted up my computer today and looked in the event log and noticed some errors from Macrium Reflect . Event ID 7000. The MacriumService service failed to start due to the following error: The service did not respond to the start or control request in a timely...

Users found this page by searching for:

  1. macrium and rollback