Windows 10: Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files?

Discus and support Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files? in Windows 10 Backup and Restore to solve the problem; -I have a 2TB external HD (lets call this ExHD_1) that I am currently using to create 'Images' of only my SSD. I think having 2 months worth of the SSD... Discussion in 'Windows 10 Backup and Restore' started by C0zzie, Oct 29, 2017.

  1. C0zzie Win User

    Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files?

    -I have a 2TB external HD (lets call this ExHD_1) that I am currently using to create 'Images' of only my SSD. I think having 2 months worth of the SSD image is enough, then when I create a new one, I then delete the one at the back of the queue...if that makes sense...

    -Anyway, I also currently manually backup personal file i.e photos, documents,music, work projects, onto another separate 2TB external HD (lets call this ExHD_2). So this is 1 form of backing up files so far!

    -People say to backup your important work multiple times, so I am wondering..
    Can I use 'ExHD_1' to, not only store my Macrium Images of my SSD, but to also store personal files, like the photos, important projects etc?
    I understand the whole restoring method, although I havent actually done it before, my rescue CD works and I plugged my ExHD_1 and was able to locate the 'SSD Images'.
    I feel that having important files, as well as the images, will cause a confusion when (if I was to restore), and the personal files would be removed or something like that?

    Is this completely safe to do so? Use ExHD_1 for both images and personal files?

    Many Thanks! *Smile

    C0zzie, Oct 29, 2017
  2. Time Lady Win User

    Windows 10 Start Menu and Cortana - Window's won't update

    Then it sounds like a clean install is needed.

    You could use Macrium Reflect to backup/image your pc an external hard drive then your personal files will be safe.
    Time Lady, Oct 29, 2017
  3. Phil_A1 Win User
    Loading an image (Macrium Reflect) of my C drive into a brand-new pc to retain browser settings, etc.

    Thanks for the reply Gordon. So, connect the external HD that has the image, to the new pc, boot it up, and then run the 'restore' function of Macrium Reflect, for that particular image, is that correct?
    Phil_A1, Oct 29, 2017
  4. simrick Win User

    Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files?

    Best practice for backups is the 3-2-1 method: 3 total backups, 2 local/swapped at regular intervals, 1 off-site.

    So, in your case, I would use eHD1, make system images and data images on it, then regularly swap it out with eHD2, making the same types of images. Lastly, I would look into some sort of cloud storage, or an eHD3 to store at a neighbor's or in a bank vault.

    The eHDs 1&2 should be swapped, so that they are not connected to the computer at the same time. This will help protect against the type of ransomware which encrypts everything attached to your system.

    In the Macrium instructions set, you can tell it to keep a certain number of backups, so it will automatically delete the extras, to keep your drives from filling up.

    Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files? [​IMG]

    You can also tell Macrium to make (for example) a full image every week, and a differential every day, in the auto-schedule.

    The eHD1 and eHD2 should have two folders on them: one for system images and one for data, and they should be the same names on each drive, so that when you swap drives, Macrium finds the folders it's looking for, no matter which is connected to the computer. It will also help you when you are looking for images to restore.


    You should also add the boot menu recovery option to your system:

    Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files? [​IMG]

    That way, you don't need to use the separate boot media, unless your drive has actually failed.

    Backup and Restore with Macrium Reflect Backup Restore Tutorials

    simrick, Oct 29, 2017
  5. JJG10 Win User
    That sounds exactly like what I do. Have done it since Paragon's backup and now Macrium.

    The process has never failed me as has saved me many times.
    JJG10, Oct 29, 2017
  6. C0zzie Win User
    Thanks guys

    When you say the eHD1 and eHD2 should have a folder called 'data', are you talking about my personal files; photos, music, work etc?

    Also thanks for the advice on backing up, however personally I just create an image once a week of my SSD manually. I sort of started using differential backup when I just had my hdd, but it just became annoying and also pointless.
    But since getting the SSD I image that on eHD1, and with work/photos/music etc on my internal HD, I also manually copy/paste on eHD2

    If I add new photos, work, music etc, I just pop in my ExHD_2 and manually copy and paste, which is why I dont bother with differential

    I dont quite understand this swapping out the harddrives so you get no ransomware. All I am doing is plugging in external hd and backing up

    And I just wanted to know if its perfectly normal to have both 'images' and 'personal data (photos, projects etc) both on 1 HD. There wont be an issue IF I have to restore. The personal data will still be on the eHD1?
    C0zzie, Oct 29, 2017
  7. simrick Win User
    Yes, you could have 2 folders on the external hard drives, one called System and one called Data.

    I assume you have your operating system on the SSD, and your data on the internal mechanical hard drive, yes?
    My point is, you don't have to manually do this. Macrium can be set up to make the backups of both the operating system (SSD) and the data (mechanical drive), automatically. You don't have to keep track of what personal files are new. You don't have to remember to make your backups. All you have to do is remember to swap external hard drives on a regular basis.

    If you are doing weekly images, and your last image was 6 days ago, and, say you get hit with a virus, or a drive fails, your backup is 6 days old. Why not let Macrium make weekly full images and daily differentials? That way, you'd be able to restore your system back one day.

    Also, copy/paste is not completely reliable. Macrium has a "verify" function, to be sure the backups are good. Even the Robocopy function in Windows would be a better way to go than a simple copy/paste for your data, to be sure it is intact.

    Most encryption ransomware will encrypt everything connected to the system, even mapped drives and shares. So, the only way to truly ensure something doesn't get hit, would be to have it disconnected from the computer. You leave one external hard drive connected while the other is not, and let Macrium do all the backups automatically. Then you swap. Plugging in drives constantly can wear out connections prematurely.

    Not a problem at all. Just keep them in separate folders.
    simrick, Oct 29, 2017
  8. RolandJS Win User

    Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files?

    To help prevent ransomware from encrypting original and backup copies of data folders' files -- any external device being used as a container of backups should not remain plugged in the computer 24/7, rather, should only be plugged in during a backup process -- I think that was one gist of previous posts *Smile
    RolandJS, Oct 29, 2017
  9. C0zzie Win User
    Yes you are correct, SSD store the OS (and my games/software), and internal HD stores my photos, work, music etc

    Ye I do see your points, but doesn't a differential image (I need to purchase Macrium for Incremental to work) create a certain Macrium file type? Or does it actually 'copy and paste' the updated file from your PC to your external HD?

    I honestly dont have an issue with manually backing up, so I think I am ok with this.
    I literally just remember to make 1 full image of my SSD per week, and whenever I edit/work on my important projects, add photos from phone to PC, etc, I plug in myExHD_2 and copy and paste it to that (which I have been doing for years, and I am sure millions of people do?..

    Also, I dont really like to have, not only an external HD always plugged in, but having to change it weekly also. But I do appreciate the advice/tips you have given me, this has given me more insight into what Macrium can do!

    Thank You very much *Smile
    C0zzie, Oct 29, 2017
  10. simrick Win User
    The Macrium "image" is a compressed file, and yes, both full images and differentials are in this format. Macrium images can be "mounted" using the Macrium program, and particular files can be extracted if desired. So, the images take up much less space, yet the data is fully accessible.

    Welcome! *Smile
    simrick, Apr 5, 2018

Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files?

  1. Safe to use external HD for both 'Macrium Images' and Personal files? - Similar Threads - Safe external both

  2. Transferring files to external HD

    in Windows 10 Ask Insider
    Transferring files to external HD: I just bought a WD easystore 2tb external hard drive, I also have an old HP slim line s5-1414 PC that is running windows 10. when I transfer a file from the PC to the external hard drive the file still appears on the PC. I’m trying to save space on the computer. I’m...
  3. Rename Macrium Image File?

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Rename Macrium Image File?: I was recently trying out Macrium Free 7.2 and a couple of questions came up. I created a disk image and left the settings at defaults. There was the part of the process where you direct the file to the destination folder, and this is where there was a warning to NOT change...
  4. Image restore problem using Macrium Reflect

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Image restore problem using Macrium Reflect: I made an Image backup of Windows 10 64 Bit the other day using the free version of Macrium Reflect v.7. I am having a spot of trouble on my Dell laptop and decided I would restore the system from Macrium. What I failed to do, I am beginning to understand, was to make the...
  5. Macrium Reflect Restoring a Failed HD Image

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect Restoring a Failed HD Image: I have been finding my way. While I can navigate through my original file tree in the image I am now inferring that I cannot directly extract portions of it, say my User files. Restoring an image is an all or nothing proposition?. Is this correct? If so I am thinking...
  6. Is it safe to use both Kaspersky and Windows Defender?

    in AntiVirus, Firewalls and System Security
    Is it safe to use both Kaspersky and Windows Defender?: Is it safe to use both Kaspersky and Windows Defender? Or it is better completely disable windows defender and only use Kaspersky? 99524
  7. Redeploy Image File macrium

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Redeploy Image File macrium: I bought a new laptop. wanted to move the image from old to it . size of the image is 258gig. Did the restore fine. Ran Redeploy fine. When running Fix Windows Boot Problems the screen that shows Boot Code Options has four choices. Three are grayed out and you cannot...
  8. Macrium Reflect does not find image file

    in Windows 10 Backup and Restore
    Macrium Reflect does not find image file: Been trying M. Reflect free edition on a Dell Studio XPS 8000. I did as usual and created a boot rescue CD with the PE file with no problem. Then I continued to make an image of my boot disk C and save it on my hard drive D. Went to D and the image is there. Next I booted...
  9. External HD space not restored after deleting macrium image.

    in Windows 10 Performance & Maintenance
    External HD space not restored after deleting macrium image.: I booted with macrium 7.1 rescue media usb stick. After verifying new image, deleted old image. As there is no recycle bin, I thought it is permenantly deleted. But when I booted, I found space not restored for deledted image. I made one more image again in normal laptop...
  10. Macrium viBoot - Create Virtual Machine using Macrium Image

    in Windows 10 Tutorials
    Macrium viBoot - Create Virtual Machine using Macrium Image: How to: Macrium viBoot - Create Virtual Machine using Macrium Image [img] Information I want to start with a very subjective, personal opinion: Macrium Reflect Free is the best available free imaging solution for Windows (download: Macrium Reflect Free). That being...